• ECS
  • 27 Jan 2021

Is Your Email Marketing Working As Per Your Expectations?

Email marketing remains a useful digital marketing channel for businesses looking to connect with customers, promote products and services, and build long-term relationships. However, simply sending regular emails does not guarantee that a campaign will deliver the expected results.

Many businesses hesitate to invest in email marketing because they assume people rarely open promotional emails. In reality, email can still be an effective way to reach an interested audience, provided campaigns are relevant, well-timed and properly managed.

The important question is not how many emails you send, but how people respond to them.

Are subscribers opening your emails? Are they clicking through to your website? Are those visits leading to enquiries, purchases or other valuable actions?

By tracking the right email marketing metrics, you can understand what is working, identify problems and improve future campaigns.

Why Is Email Marketing Effective?

Email marketing gives businesses a direct way to communicate with people who have chosen to receive their updates. Unlike some advertising channels, it allows companies to share information with an existing audience through a channel they regularly use.

When planned carefully, email marketing can help businesses:

  • Generate sales: Share product updates, special offers and relevant recommendations with potential customers.
  • Build customer loyalty: Keep customers informed about useful information, new products and company updates.
  • Encourage repeat purchases: Remind existing customers about products and services they may need again.
  • Generate business leads: Direct interested subscribers towards enquiry forms, landing pages and service information.
  • Support cost-effective marketing: Reach an existing subscriber list without relying entirely on paid advertising.
  • Maintain customer relationships: Share helpful content and stay connected between purchases.

However, results depend on factors such as audience quality, campaign content, timing, industry and the purpose of the email. Measuring performance is essential to understanding whether your investment is worthwhile.

How Well Is Your Email Marketing Performing?

You may already be sending newsletters, promotional offers and business updates. But are these emails producing meaningful results?

The following metrics can help you evaluate your email marketing performance.

1. Email Open Rate and Subject Line Performance

Getting subscribers to open an email is an important early step in a campaign. Your subject line helps recipients decide whether the message is worth their attention.

A clear, relevant subject line can encourage people to open an email, while vague or overly promotional wording may be ignored.

To improve subject line performance:

  • Keep subject lines concise and easy to understand.
  • Explain the main benefit or purpose of the email.
  • Use personalisation only when it is relevant.
  • Avoid misleading promises and excessive promotional language.
  • Test different subject lines to identify what works for your audience.

You should also be careful when interpreting open rates. Email privacy features, particularly Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection, can affect how opens are recorded. As a result, open rates are best treated as an indicative metric rather than a completely reliable measure of engagement.

Look at open rate alongside clicks, conversions and other campaign results.

2. Track Sales and Conversions

The ultimate purpose of many email campaigns is to encourage customers to take action. This might involve purchasing a product, requesting a quotation, booking a service or signing up for an event.

Tracking conversions helps you understand whether your emails are contributing to business results.

One way to measure this is by using unique discount codes or promotional links in your campaigns. When customers use a specific code, you can identify purchases associated with that promotion.

For more accurate tracking, consider:

  • Using unique coupon codes for individual campaigns.
  • Adding UTM parameters to links.
  • Tracking purchases through website analytics.
  • Measuring enquiries and completed forms.
  • Comparing campaign results with your marketing objectives.

For example, if you send an email promoting a new product collection, you can track how many recipients visit the collection page and complete a purchase.

Remember that not every email campaign is designed to generate immediate sales. A newsletter might aim to increase website visits, while an educational email may focus on building trust and encouraging future enquiries.

Choose conversion goals that match the purpose of each campaign.

3. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

Click-through rate measures how many delivered emails generate clicks on one or more links within the message.

It helps you understand whether subscribers find your email content useful enough to take the next step.

For example, if your email introduces a new service, the click-through rate can show whether subscribers are interested in learning more.

To improve click-through rates:

  • Include links that are relevant to the email topic.
  • Use clear calls to action.
  • Make important links easy to find.
  • Keep the message focused on one primary objective.
  • Ensure landing pages provide the information promised in the email.
  • Test different content formats and link placements.

It is useful to distinguish between click-through rate and click-to-open rate. Click-through rate generally measures clicks against delivered emails, while click-to-open rate measures clicks against recorded opens.

A low click-through rate may indicate that the content, offer or call to action needs improvement. However, always consider the campaign’s objective before judging the result.

4. Unengaged Subscriber Rate

Not every person who subscribes to your mailing list will continue interacting with your emails.

Some subscribers may stop opening messages, while others may occasionally read them without clicking. Over time, a large number of inactive subscribers can make it harder to understand how well your campaigns are performing.

Instead of immediately removing every inactive contact, first review their engagement history and consider whether they should receive a re-engagement campaign.

You can improve subscriber list management by:

  • Identifying subscribers who have not engaged for an extended period.
  • Sending a relevant re-engagement email.
  • Reviewing whether your content matches subscriber interests.
  • Offering preference options so subscribers can choose what they receive.
  • Removing invalid or persistently inactive contacts when appropriate.

A smaller, genuinely interested email list can be more valuable than a large list containing many inactive contacts.

5. Unsubscribe Rate

The unsubscribe rate shows the percentage of recipients who choose to leave your mailing list after receiving an email.

Some unsubscribes are normal. People change interests, reduce the number of promotional emails they receive or no longer need a particular service.

However, a sudden increase in unsubscribes may indicate that something needs attention.

Possible reasons include:

  • Sending emails too frequently.
  • Sharing irrelevant or repetitive content.
  • Using misleading subject lines.
  • Sending promotions that do not match subscriber expectations.
  • Failing to provide useful information.
  • Not giving subscribers control over their email preferences.

If unsubscribe rates increase, review the campaign content, frequency and audience targeting. Make sure subscribers understand what they are signing up for and receive the type of communication they expected.

6. Email Bounce Rate

Bounce rate measures the percentage of emails that could not be delivered successfully.

There are two main types:

  • Hard bounce: An email cannot be delivered because the address is invalid, does not exist or has another permanent delivery problem.
  • Soft bounce: An email cannot be delivered temporarily, perhaps because the recipient’s inbox is full or the receiving server is unavailable.

A high bounce rate can indicate problems with list quality or email delivery.

To reduce bounces, use confirmed subscriber addresses, remove invalid contacts and avoid purchasing email lists. Regularly review your mailing list and follow your email platform’s recommended list management practices.

7. Return on Email Marketing Investment

Email marketing performance should also be considered in terms of business value.

Return on investment (ROI) helps you compare the revenue or value generated by a campaign with the costs involved in running it.

Depending on your business, costs may include email marketing software, campaign design, content creation and staff time.

A basic ROI calculation is:

[
ROI = \frac{\text{Revenue Generated} – \text{Campaign Cost}}{\text{Campaign Cost}} \times 100
]

For example, if a campaign costs £200 and generates £800 in attributable revenue, its ROI is 300%.

This calculation is only useful when revenue attribution is reasonably reliable. For campaigns designed to generate leads or improve customer retention, you may need to measure lead value or other business outcomes instead of immediate sales.

How to Improve Your Email Marketing Results

Tracking metrics is only useful when you act on what the data tells you. Once you understand your campaign performance, use the findings to improve future emails.

Here are some practical ways to strengthen your email marketing strategy:

Segment Your Subscribers: Divide your audience into relevant groups based on interests, previous purchases or engagement. This allows you to send more suitable messages.

Personalise Email Content: Use relevant subscriber information to make emails more useful. Personalisation should improve the message rather than simply insert a recipient’s name.

Test Different Subject Lines: Experiment with different subject lines and compare the results. A/B testing can help identify which approach works better for a particular audience.

Make Emails Mobile-Friendly: Many subscribers read emails on mobile devices. Use readable text, clear layouts and buttons that are easy to tap.

Send Emails at Suitable Times: Test different sending times and days rather than assuming there is one perfect schedule for every audience.

Provide Useful Content: Balance promotional messages with helpful information, product guidance, updates and other content that subscribers actually want to receive.

Review Performance Regularly: Compare campaigns over time and look for changes in engagement, conversions, unsubscribes and delivery rates.

Final Thoughts

Successful email marketing is about more than sending promotional messages to a large subscriber list. It requires a clear strategy, relevant content, proper audience targeting and regular performance analysis.

Open rates, click-through rates, conversions, inactive subscribers, unsubscribes, bounce rates and campaign ROI can all help you understand whether your email marketing is meeting its objectives.

Review these metrics regularly, identify areas that need improvement and adjust your campaigns based on actual subscriber behaviour.

With consistent testing and thoughtful optimisation, email marketing can become a valuable part of your wider digital marketing strategy.